Cases: Difference between revisions

From AI Law Wiki
(Fix blank line breaking list in Recent Developments)
(Add Pennsylvania v. Character.AI to Consumer Protection cases)
 
(7 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:


=== Copyright Cases ===
=== Copyright Cases ===
* Tumbler Ridge families sue OpenAI — seven families file wrongful death suit after school shooting, alleging OpenAI failed to alert police of shooter's ChatGPT activity (April 29, 2026). ''See: [[News-Tumbler-Ridge-Families-Sue-OpenAI-2026|News article]]''
* [[Getty Images v Stability AI]] — Getty Images alleges Stable Diffusion trained on copyrighted images; motion to dismiss mostly denied April 2026
* [[Getty Images v Stability AI]] — Getty Images alleges Stable Diffusion trained on copyrighted images; motion to dismiss mostly denied April 2026
* [[Kadrey v Meta Platforms Inc]] — Authors allege Meta trained LLaMA on pirated books
* [[Kadrey v Meta Platforms Inc]] — Authors allege Meta trained LLaMA on pirated books
Line 19: Line 18:
* [[BMG Rights Management v Anthropic PBC]] — Music publisher sues over 493 song lyrics used in AI training (March 2026)
* [[BMG Rights Management v Anthropic PBC]] — Music publisher sues over 493 song lyrics used in AI training (March 2026)
* [[Reddit Inc v Anthropic PBC]] — Reddit sues Anthropic over unauthorized scraping for AI training; remanded to state court (March 2026)
* [[Reddit Inc v Anthropic PBC]] — Reddit sues Anthropic over unauthorized scraping for AI training; remanded to state court (March 2026)
* [[News Reddit v Anthropic Remand 2026|April 2026 — Reddit v. Anthropic — Federal court remands case to state court, rejects copyright preemption]]
* [[Gracenote Media Services v OpenAI]] — Nielsen subsidiary sues OpenAI over unauthorized use of copyrighted media metadata database for AI training (March 2026)
* [[Gracenote Media Services v OpenAI]] — Nielsen subsidiary sues OpenAI over unauthorized use of copyrighted media metadata database for AI training (March 2026)
* [[Encyclopaedia Britannica v OpenAI Inc]] — Britannica and Merriam-Webster sue OpenAI for scraping 100K articles/dictionary entries to train ChatGPT (March 2026)
* [[Encyclopaedia Britannica v OpenAI Inc]] — Britannica and Merriam-Webster sue OpenAI for scraping 100K articles/dictionary entries to train ChatGPT (March 2026)
Line 26: Line 24:
* [[Disney Enterprises v MiniMax]] — Hollywood studios sue Chinese AI company over AI-generated character images; motions to dismiss filed April 2026 (September 2025)
* [[Disney Enterprises v MiniMax]] — Hollywood studios sue Chinese AI company over AI-generated character images; motions to dismiss filed April 2026 (September 2025)
* [[GEMA v Suno]] — German performing rights organization sues Suno AI for unauthorized use of copyrighted musical compositions for AI training; ruling scheduled June 12, 2026 (January 2025)
* [[GEMA v Suno]] — German performing rights organization sues Suno AI for unauthorized use of copyrighted musical compositions for AI training; ruling scheduled June 12, 2026 (January 2025)
* [[Lyon v Adobe Inc]] — Author Douglas Lyon consolidated complaint against Adobe (filed April 2026)


=== Employment Discrimination Cases ===
=== Employment Discrimination Cases ===
Line 37: Line 36:
* [[Nippon Life v OpenAI Foundation|Nippon Life v. OpenAI Foundation]] — Insurer sues OpenAI for unlicensed practice of law via ChatGPT (March 2026)
* [[Nippon Life v OpenAI Foundation|Nippon Life v. OpenAI Foundation]] — Insurer sues OpenAI for unlicensed practice of law via ChatGPT (March 2026)
* [[Kistler v Eightfold AI Inc|Kistler v. Eightfold AI Inc.]] — FCRA class action challenging AI hiring tools as consumer reports (January 2026)
* [[Kistler v Eightfold AI Inc|Kistler v. Eightfold AI Inc.]] — FCRA class action challenging AI hiring tools as consumer reports (January 2026)
* '''Settled''': [[News-Apple-Siri-Settlement-May-2026|Apple Siri False Advertising Settlement]] (N.D. Cal., 2026) — $250M class action settlement over delayed AI Siri features promoted with iPhone 16. ''Settled May 2026.''
* [[News-Pennsylvania-v-Character-AI-Medical-2026|Pennsylvania v. Character Technologies Inc.]] — Pennsylvania AG sues Character.AI over chatbot posing as licensed medical professional, alleging unlicensed practice of medicine (May 2026)


=== Product Liability and Wrongful Death Cases ===
=== Product Liability and Wrongful Death Cases ===
* [[Gavalas v Google LLC|Gavalas v. Google LLC]] — Father sues Google for wrongful death, alleging Gemini AI chatbot manipulated son into suicide; ICMC set June 2
* [[Gavalas v Google LLC|Gavalas v. Google LLC]] — Father sues Google for wrongful death, alleging Gemini AI chatbot manipulated son into suicide; ICMC set June 2
* [[Huballa v Google LLC]] — Multiple plaintiffs sue Google over Gemini AI chatbot (removed to federal court April 2026)
* [[Huballa v Google LLC]] — Multiple plaintiffs sue Google over Gemini AI chatbot (removed to federal court April 2026)
* Tumbler Ridge families sue OpenAI — seven families file wrongful death suit after school shooting, alleging OpenAI failed to alert police of shooter's ChatGPT activity (April 29, 2026). ''See: [[News-Tumbler-Ridge-Families-Sue-OpenAI-2026|News article]]''
=== Child Safety Cases ===
* [[New Mexico v Meta Platforms Inc]] — State of New Mexico sues Meta for child safety violations; $375M civil penalties assessed; remedies trial begins May 2026
* [[Doe v X.AI Corp]] — Minors allege xAI's Grok AI generated CSAM deepfakes from their real photographs; class action under Masha's Law and TVPA (March 2026)


=== Privilege and Work Product Cases ===
=== Privilege and Work Product Cases ===
Line 54: Line 60:
* [[XAI Corp v Weiser|xAI v. Weiser]] — xAI challenges Colorado AI Act on constitutional grounds; DOJ intervenes alongside xAI (2025–present)
* [[XAI Corp v Weiser|xAI v. Weiser]] — xAI challenges Colorado AI Act on constitutional grounds; DOJ intervenes alongside xAI (2025–present)


== == Recent Developments ==
== Recent Developments ==
* '''May 5, 2026''': [[News-Google-MS-xAI-CAISI-Early-Model-Access-May-2026|Google, Microsoft, xAI Join CAISI]] — Three major AI companies join OpenAI and Anthropic in granting the U.S. Commerce Department early access to frontier AI models for evaluation
* '''May 5, 2026''': [[News-Apple-Siri-Settlement-May-2026|Apple $250M Siri Settlement]] — Apple settles class action over false advertising of delayed AI Siri features
* '''May 4, 2026''': [[News-May-04-2026|May 4, 2026]] — EU compute plan criticized, Anthropic finalizes $1.5B Blackstone JV, unions back data centers, artist sues AI startup over comic
* '''May 4, 2026''': [[News-May-04-2026|May 4, 2026]] — EU compute plan criticized, Anthropic finalizes $1.5B Blackstone JV, unions back data centers, artist sues AI startup over comic
* '''May 3, 2026''': [[News-May-03-2026|May 3, 2026]] — Pentagon awards 7 AI contracts, Oscars establish AI rules, ModelForge sued over Instagram scraping
* '''May 3, 2026''': [[News-May-03-2026|May 3, 2026]] — Pentagon awards 7 AI contracts, Oscars establish AI rules, ModelForge sued over Instagram scraping
Line 60: Line 68:
* '''May 1, 2026''': [[News-Amazon-Rufus-AI-Lawsuit-May-2026|Amazon Sued Over AI Rufus]] — Class action alleges children's sunscreens sold on Amazon contain lead and that Rufus AI shopping assistant fails to disclose product safety information.
* '''May 1, 2026''': [[News-Amazon-Rufus-AI-Lawsuit-May-2026|Amazon Sued Over AI Rufus]] — Class action alleges children's sunscreens sold on Amazon contain lead and that Rufus AI shopping assistant fails to disclose product safety information.
* '''April 30, 2026''': [[News New Mexico v Meta Shutdown Threat 2026|Meta threatens NM shutdown]] — Meta warns it may withdraw Facebook/Instagram from New Mexico if state judge orders sweeping child safety features.
* '''April 30, 2026''': [[News New Mexico v Meta Shutdown Threat 2026|Meta threatens NM shutdown]] — Meta warns it may withdraw Facebook/Instagram from New Mexico if state judge orders sweeping child safety features.
* '''April 27, 2026''': [[News Musk v Altman Trial Begins April 27 2026|Musk v. Altman bench trial begins with advisory jury selection in Oakland — Elon Musk's charitable trust and unjust enrichment claims against OpenAI cofounders go to trial<ref name="reuters-trial">[https://www.reuters.com/technology/elon-musks-trial-against-sam-altman-reveal-ongoing-power-struggle-openai-2026-04-27/ Reuters, Elon Musk's trial against Sam Altman to reveal the ongoing power struggle for OpenAI]</ref>
* '''April 27, 2026''': [[News Musk v Altman Trial Begins April 27 2026|Musk v. Altman bench trial begins with advisory jury selection in Oakland — Elon Musk's charitable trust and unjust enrichment claims against OpenAI cofounders go to trial]]<ref name="reuters-trial">[https://www.reuters.com/technology/elon-musks-trial-against-sam-altman-reveal-ongoing-power-struggle-openai-2026-04-27/ Reuters, Elon Musk's trial against Sam Altman to reveal the ongoing power struggle for OpenAI]</ref>
* '''April 24, 2026''': [[News DOJ Joins xAI Colorado AI Law Challenge 2026|DOJ intervenes in xAI v. Weiser, siding with xAI's challenge to Colorado SB 24-205 in the first federal intervention against a state AI law<ref name="bloomberg-doj">[https://news.bgov.com/business-and-practice/doj-joins-musks-xai-suit-against-colorado-ai-discrimination-law Bloomberg Law, DOJ Joins Musk's xAI Suit Against Colorado AI Discrimination Law]</ref>
* '''April 24, 2026''': [[News DOJ Joins xAI Colorado AI Law Challenge 2026|DOJ intervenes in xAI v. Weiser, siding with xAI's challenge to Colorado SB 24-205 in the first federal intervention against a state AI law]]<ref name="bloomberg-doj">[https://news.bgov.com/business-and-practice/doj-joins-musks-xai-suit-against-colorado-ai-discrimination-law Bloomberg Law, DOJ Joins Musk's xAI Suit Against Colorado AI Discrimination Law]</ref>
* [[News Musk v OpenAI Trial April 2026|April 2026 — Musk v. Altman Trial Begins — Bench trial with advisory jury starts April 27; Musk dropped fraud claims April 24-25, case narrowed to breach of charitable trust and unjust enrichment]]
* [[News Musk v OpenAI Trial April 2026|April 2026 — Musk v. Altman Trial Begins — Bench trial with advisory jury starts April 27; Musk dropped fraud claims April 24-25, case narrowed to breach of charitable trust and unjust enrichment]]
* [[News Florida AG Criminal Investigation OpenAI 2026|April 2026 — Florida AG Criminal Investigation — First criminal probe of an AI company; AG Uthmeier investigates OpenAI over FSU shooting]]
* [[News Florida AG Criminal Investigation OpenAI 2026|April 2026 — Florida AG Criminal Investigation — First criminal probe of an AI company; AG Uthmeier investigates OpenAI over FSU shooting]]
Line 76: Line 84:
* [[News Ted Entertainment Sues OpenAI Apple Amazon DMCA 2026|April 2026 — Ted Entertainment DMCA Suits — YouTubers sue OpenAI, Apple, Amazon for DMCA video scraping]]
* [[News Ted Entertainment Sues OpenAI Apple Amazon DMCA 2026|April 2026 — Ted Entertainment DMCA Suits — YouTubers sue OpenAI, Apple, Amazon for DMCA video scraping]]
* [[News Gracenote Media Services v OpenAI 2026|March 2026 — Gracenote v. OpenAI — Nielsen subsidiary sues OpenAI over metadata database]]
* [[News Gracenote Media Services v OpenAI 2026|March 2026 — Gracenote v. OpenAI — Nielsen subsidiary sues OpenAI over metadata database]]
* [[News Reddit v Anthropic Remand 2026|April 2026 — Reddit v. Anthropic — Federal court remands case to state court, rejects copyright preemption]]
== References ==
<references />


== Categories ==
[[Category:Copyright Litigation]]
=== Child Safety Cases ===
* [[New Mexico v Meta Platforms Inc]] — State of New Mexico sues Meta for child safety violations; $375M civil penalties assessed; remedies trial begins May 2026
* [[Doe v X.AI Corp]] — Minors allege xAI's Grok AI generated CSAM deepfakes from their real photographs; class action under Masha's Law and TVPA (March 2026)
* [[Disney v MiniMax]] Film studios copyright suit against Chinese video-generation company (filed March 2026)
* [[Lyon v Adobe Inc]] Author Douglas Lyon consolidated complaint against Adobe (filed April 2026)
* [[Category:Copyright Litigation]]
[[Category:Consumer Protection]]
[[Category:Consumer Protection]]
[[Category:Child Safety]]
[[Category:Child Safety]]
[[Category:Product Liability]]
[[Category:Product Liability]]
[[Category:Corporate Governance]]
[[Category:Corporate Governance]]

Latest revision as of 01:12, 7 May 2026

This page tracks active and significant AI-related legal cases, including copyright disputes, privacy litigation, and regulatory challenges.

Active Litigation

Copyright Cases

Employment Discrimination Cases

  • Mobley v Workday Inc — AI hiring tools vendor liability for age/race/disability discrimination; conditional ADEA collective action certified (May 2025)

Corporate Governance Cases

Consumer Protection and Unlicensed Practice Cases

Product Liability and Wrongful Death Cases

  • Gavalas v. Google LLC — Father sues Google for wrongful death, alleging Gemini AI chatbot manipulated son into suicide; ICMC set June 2
  • Huballa v Google LLC — Multiple plaintiffs sue Google over Gemini AI chatbot (removed to federal court April 2026)
  • Tumbler Ridge families sue OpenAI — seven families file wrongful death suit after school shooting, alleging OpenAI failed to alert police of shooter's ChatGPT activity (April 29, 2026). See: News article

Child Safety Cases

  • New Mexico v Meta Platforms Inc — State of New Mexico sues Meta for child safety violations; $375M civil penalties assessed; remedies trial begins May 2026
  • Doe v X.AI Corp — Minors allege xAI's Grok AI generated CSAM deepfakes from their real photographs; class action under Masha's Law and TVPA (March 2026)

Privilege and Work Product Cases

  • United States v Heppner — First ruling on AI-generated materials and privilege: public AI tool use not protected (S.D.N.Y., February 2026)
  • Warner v Gilbarco — Paired ruling: pro se plaintiff's AI-assisted materials protected under work product doctrine (E.D. Mich., February 2026)

Patent and Authorship Cases

Constitutional and Regulatory Challenges

  • Anthropic PBC v U.S. Department of War — AI company challenges Trump administration supply-chain risk designation as First Amendment retaliation; preliminary injunction granted March 26, 2026
  • XAI v Bonta — xAI challenges California AB 2013 AI training data transparency law on First Amendment, Takings, and Due Process grounds; preliminary injunction denied March 4, 2026 (December 2025)
  • xAI v. Weiser — xAI challenges Colorado AI Act on constitutional grounds; DOJ intervenes alongside xAI (2025–present)

Recent Developments

References