Jump to content

Cases: Difference between revisions

From AI Law Wiki
Add ANI Media v. OpenAI to active copyright cases
Index Chamberlain v. Granola privacy class action
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 29: Line 29:
* [[Chmura v Snap Inc]] — YouTuber sues Snap Inc for DMCA circumvention in AI video training (February 2026)
* [[Chmura v Snap Inc]] — YouTuber sues Snap Inc for DMCA circumvention in AI video training (February 2026)
* [[Disney Enterprises v MiniMax]] — Hollywood studios sue Chinese AI company over AI-generated character images; motions to dismiss filed April 2026 (September 2025)
* [[Disney Enterprises v MiniMax]] — Hollywood studios sue Chinese AI company over AI-generated character images; motions to dismiss filed April 2026 (September 2025)
* [[GEMA v Suno]] — German performing rights organization sues Suno AI for unauthorized use of copyrighted musical compositions for AI training; ruling scheduled June 12, 2026 (January 2025)
* [[GEMA v Suno]] — Munich Regional Court ruled for GEMA on July 31, 2026, finding copyright infringement in six represented works; revenue disclosure and damages proceedings remain, and Suno is considering an appeal. ''See: [[News-July-31-2026|July 31, 2026 coverage]]''<ref name="star-suno-july31">[https://www.thestar.com.my/tech/tech-news/2026/07/31/german-court-rules-ai-music-firm-suno-broke-copyright-rules Reuters via The Star, “German court rules AI music firm Suno broke copyright rules,” July 31, 2026]</ref>
* [[Lyon v Adobe Inc]] — Author Douglas Lyon consolidated complaint against Adobe (filed April 2026)
* [[Lyon v Adobe Inc]] — Author Douglas Lyon consolidated complaint against Adobe (filed April 2026)


Line 37: Line 37:


=== Corporate Governance Cases ===
=== Corporate Governance Cases ===
* '''[[Berliner v Huang et al|''Berliner v. Huang et al.'']]''' — NVIDIA stockholder derivative action alleging that officers and directors exposed the company to copyright and biometric-privacy liability through AI-training practices. ''See: [[News-July-31-2026|July 31, 2026 coverage]]''<ref name="cns-nvidia-derivative">[https://www.courthousenews.com/investors-blast-nvidia-over-avalanche-of-ai-copyright-suits/ Courthouse News Service, “Investors blast Nvidia over avalanche of AI copyright suits,” August 3, 2026]</ref>
* [[Musk v Altman et al]] — Elon Musk sues OpenAI cofounders for breach of charitable trust and unjust enrichment (fraud claims dropped April 25, 2026); bench trial with advisory jury began April 27, 2026; [[News-April-29-2026|Musk testified April 28]]
* [[Musk v Altman et al]] — Elon Musk sues OpenAI cofounders for breach of charitable trust and unjust enrichment (fraud claims dropped April 25, 2026); bench trial with advisory jury began April 27, 2026; [[News-April-29-2026|Musk testified April 28]]
* [[SEIU Pension Plan Master Trust v Narayen]] — First shareholder derivative suit against AI company executives for AI training on copyrighted works (filed April 24, 2026)
* [[SEIU Pension Plan Master Trust v Narayen]] — First shareholder derivative suit against AI company executives for AI training on copyrighted works (filed April 24, 2026)
=== Defamation Cases ===
* '''[[Starbuck v Google LLC|''Starbuck v. Google LLC'']]''' — Robert Starbuck alleges Google AI generated and published false statements accusing him of crimes and misconduct; Google's motion to dismiss was denied July 24, 2026. ''See: [[News-July-24-2026|July 24, 2026 coverage]]''
=== Privacy Cases ===
* '''[[Chamberlain v Granola Inc|''Chamberlain v. Granola Inc.'']]''' — proposed class action alleging Granola’s AI note-taking app recorded and transcribed conversations without all participants’ consent and used transcription data for AI-model training. ''See: [[News-July-30-2026|July 30, 2026 coverage]]''


=== Consumer Protection and Unlicensed Practice Cases ===
=== Consumer Protection and Unlicensed Practice Cases ===
Line 98: Line 105:
* [[News Nippon Life Sues OpenAI Unlicensed Law Practice 2026|March 2026 — Nippon Life v. OpenAI — Insurer sues OpenAI for unlicensed practice of law via ChatGPT]]
* [[News Nippon Life Sues OpenAI Unlicensed Law Practice 2026|March 2026 — Nippon Life v. OpenAI — Insurer sues OpenAI for unlicensed practice of law via ChatGPT]]
* [[News BMG Sues Anthropic Copyright Lyrics 2026|March 2026 — BMG v. Anthropic — Music publisher sues over 493 copyrighted song lyrics in AI training]]
* [[News BMG Sues Anthropic Copyright Lyrics 2026|March 2026 — BMG v. Anthropic — Music publisher sues over 493 copyrighted song lyrics in AI training]]
* [[News GEMA v Suno 2026|April 2026 — GEMA v Suno — German performing rights organization ruling scheduled June 12, 2026]]
* '''July 31, 2026''': [[GEMA v Suno|GEMA v. Suno]] Munich Regional Court rules for GEMA; revenue disclosure and damages proceedings remain. ''See: [[News-July-31-2026|July 31, 2026 coverage]]''<ref name="star-suno-july31" />
* [[News Indie Artists v Google Lyria 2026|April 2026 — Indie Artists v Google — Indie musicians sue Google over AI training on YouTube clips]]
* [[News Indie Artists v Google Lyria 2026|April 2026 — Indie Artists v Google — Indie musicians sue Google over AI training on YouTube clips]]
* [[News Anthropic 1.5B Settlement 2026|April 2026 — Anthropic Settlement — $1.5B settlement with authors; fairness hearing May 14, 2026]]
* [[News Anthropic 1.5B Settlement 2026|April 2026 — Anthropic Settlement — $1.5B settlement with authors; fairness hearing May 14, 2026]]

Latest revision as of 16:34, 6 August 2026

This page tracks active and significant AI-related legal cases, including copyright disputes, privacy litigation, and regulatory challenges.

Active Litigation

[edit]
[edit]

Employment Discrimination Cases

[edit]
  • Doe Employees v. Meta Platforms Inc. — current and former Meta employees allege AI-assisted layoff decisions discriminated against workers with disabilities or protected leave; a judge denied a temporary restraining order while leaving the preliminary-injunction request pending. See: July 20, 2026 ruling update
  • Mobley v Workday Inc — AI hiring tools vendor liability for age/race/disability discrimination; conditional ADEA collective action certified (May 2025)

Corporate Governance Cases

[edit]

Defamation Cases

[edit]
  • Starbuck v. Google LLC — Robert Starbuck alleges Google AI generated and published false statements accusing him of crimes and misconduct; Google's motion to dismiss was denied July 24, 2026. See: July 24, 2026 coverage

Privacy Cases

[edit]
  • Chamberlain v. Granola Inc. — proposed class action alleging Granola’s AI note-taking app recorded and transcribed conversations without all participants’ consent and used transcription data for AI-model training. See: July 30, 2026 coverage

Consumer Protection and Unlicensed Practice Cases

[edit]

Product Liability and Wrongful Death Cases

[edit]
  • Estate of Christian Faith Madison v. OpenAI Inc. — estate alleges ChatGPT reinforced a user's religious delusions and contributed to her death; wrongful-death and product-liability claims filed June 15, 2026. See: July 20, 2026 coverage
  • Gavalas v. Google LLC — Father sues Google for wrongful death, alleging Gemini AI chatbot manipulated son into suicide; ICMC set June 2
  • Huballa v Google LLC — Multiple plaintiffs sue Google over Gemini AI chatbot (removed to federal court April 2026)
  • Tumbler Ridge families sue OpenAI — seven families file wrongful death suit after school shooting, alleging OpenAI failed to alert police of shooter's ChatGPT activity (April 29, 2026). See: News article

Child Safety Cases

[edit]
  • New Mexico v Meta Platforms Inc — State of New Mexico sues Meta for child safety violations; $375M civil penalties assessed; remedies trial begins May 2026
  • Doe v X.AI Corp — Minors allege xAI's Grok AI generated CSAM deepfakes from their real photographs; class action under Masha's Law and TVPA (March 2026)
  • Jane Doe v. X.AI Corp. (E.D. Ark.) — family alleges xAI technology helped create or facilitate AI-generated child sexual abuse material from authentic photographs of a minor. See: July 23, 2026 coverage

Privilege and Work Product Cases

[edit]
  • United States v Heppner — First ruling on AI-generated materials and privilege: public AI tool use not protected (S.D.N.Y., February 2026)
  • Warner v Gilbarco — Paired ruling: pro se plaintiff's AI-assisted materials protected under work product doctrine (E.D. Mich., February 2026)

Patent and Authorship Cases

[edit]

Constitutional and Regulatory Challenges

[edit]
  • Anthropic PBC v U.S. Department of War — AI company challenges Trump administration supply-chain risk designation as First Amendment retaliation; preliminary injunction granted March 26, 2026
  • XAI v Bonta — xAI challenges California AB 2013 AI training data transparency law on First Amendment, Takings, and Due Process grounds; preliminary injunction denied March 4, 2026 (December 2025)
  • xAI v. Weiser — xAI challenges Colorado AI Act on constitutional grounds; DOJ intervenes alongside xAI (2025–present)

Product Liability and Personal Injury

[edit]
  • Winters v. OpenAI — Florida pastor alleges ChatGPT-4o discouraged timely medical treatment for symptoms later diagnosed as pulmonary emboli; product-liability, negligence, privacy, and unfair-competition claims filed July 22, 2026. See: July 22 coverage
  • Carrier v. OpenAI — California wrongful-death/product-liability suit alleging ChatGPT failed to intervene after repeated self-harm discussions. See: June 12 coverage

Recent Developments

[edit]

References

[edit]