Jump to content

Toronto Star Newspapers Limited v OpenAI Inc

From AI Law Wiki

AI-generated text. This page was generated using artificial intelligence.

Case Information
Case name Toronto Star Newspapers Limited et al. v. OpenAI, Inc. et al.
Court Ontario Superior Court of Justice; Court of Appeal for Ontario
Docket CV-24-00732231-00CL; COA-25-CV-1620
Filed November 28, 2024 (statement of claim electronically issued)[1]
Judge(s) Jessica Kimmel J.; Miller, Favreau and Rahman JJ.A.
Plaintiffs Toronto Star Newspapers Limited and six other Canadian news organizations
Defendants OpenAI, Inc. and affiliated entities; six entities pursued the appeal
Case type Civil copyright and contract litigation
Claims / issues Copyright infringement, breach of contract, unjust enrichment, and Ontario jurisdiction.
Status November 13, 2026: Ontario Court of Appeal dismissed the jurisdiction appeal and awarded $100,000 in agreed appeal costs.[2]

Toronto Star Newspapers Limited et al. v. OpenAI, Inc. et al. is an Ontario action by Canadian news organizations alleging that OpenAI crawled and scraped their journalism, used it to train models that power ChatGPT, and reproduced their copyrighted content for commercial purposes. The publishers plead copyright infringement, breach of contract and unjust enrichment.[2]

Jurisdiction motion

On November 7, 2025, Justice Jessica Kimmel granted the jurisdiction motion for four defendants and dismissed it for the six entities that later appealed. She found a sufficient connection to Ontario for the claims against those six and declined to stay the case in favour of a U.S. forum.[2]

November 13, 2026 jurisdiction appeal

The Court of Appeal unanimously dismissed the six entities’ appeal. It distinguished the Superior Court’s power to hear this type of claim from its jurisdiction over the particular defendants. Applying the presumptive connecting factors from Club Resorts Ltd. v. Van Breda, the panel upheld the finding of a real and substantial connection to Ontario. The record supported connections through business activities in Ontario and the alleged wrongs, including the website terms underlying the contract claims. The panel found no basis to disturb the refusal to stay the action in favour of the United States.[2]

The court awarded the publishers $100,000 in agreed appeal costs. The ruling resolves the jurisdiction challenge and leaves the merits of the publishers’ claims for later proceedings.[2]

References