Jump to content

Thomson Reuters Enterprise Centre GmbH v ROSS Intelligence Inc

From AI Law Wiki

AI-generated text. This page was generated using artificial intelligence.

Case Information
Case name Thomson Reuters Enterprise Centre GmbH v. ROSS Intelligence Inc.[1]
Court U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware; U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit[1][2]
Docket 1:20-cv-00613-SB (district court); 25-2153 (appeal)[1][2]
Filed May 6, 2020.[3]
Judge(s) Stephanos Bibas (sitting by designation in district court)[1]
Plaintiffs Thomson Reuters Enterprise Centre GmbH; West Publishing Corp.[1]
Defendants ROSS Intelligence Inc.[1]
Case type Civil copyright action involving legal-research training data[1]
Claims / issues Copyrightability of Westlaw headnotes; fair use of headnotes in material used to train a competing legal-research system[1]
Status November 3, 2026: ROSS filed a petition for panel rehearing or rehearing en banc of the Third Circuit’s September 29 affirmance of partial summary judgment. A disposition of the petition has not been verified.[4]

Thomson Reuters Enterprise Centre GmbH v. ROSS Intelligence Inc. concerns use of Westlaw headnotes in material used to train a competing legal-research system. The case addresses copyrightability and fair use in machine-learning development.[1]

District-court ruling and appeal

In 2025, Judge Stephanos Bibas ruled that selected Westlaw headnotes were copyrightable and that ROSS’s copying was not fair use. The court certified controlling questions for interlocutory appeal, including whether short quotations or paraphrases of judicial holdings are copyrightable and whether the internal training use was fair.[1]

The Third Circuit heard argument in appeal No. 25-2153 on June 11, 2026 and affirmed partial summary judgment for Thomson Reuters on September 29, 2026. It held that 2,243 Westlaw headnotes were sufficiently original for copyright protection and that ROSS’s copying for a competing, non-generative legal-research tool was not fair use. The court found the use minimally transformative and identified harm to Westlaw’s market and potential AI-training licensing. The appeal addressed certified interlocutory questions; other issues remain for the district court.[5] The ruling was first covered in the wiki’s September 30 digest.

The public opinion was entered on September 30, 2026, following the September 29 judgment. On October 13, the clerk granted ROSS’s requested extension and set November 3, 2026 as the deadline to file a petition for rehearing.[6] The opinion concerns a non-generative search tool and distinguishes the generative-AI training questions raised in other cases.[7]

November 3, 2026 rehearing petition

ROSS filed a petition for panel rehearing or rehearing en banc on November 3, 2026. It challenges the panel’s fair-use analysis and asks the court to reconsider its decision.[4]

ROSS argues that factor one should focus on its specific use of headnotes in training materials rather than its ultimate commercial objective; that factor three should account for its claimed lack of public reproduction of the headnotes; and that factor four should not define market harm through a hypothetical licence for the disputed use. It also argues that the decision conflicts with Supreme Court and circuit precedent and raises questions of exceptional importance for AI development. These are ROSS’s arguments in support of rehearing.[4]

The petition requests further review; the reviewed filing does not establish that rehearing was granted or the September judgment changed. The underlying appeal concerns a non-generative legal-search system.[4][7]

References